Best Intrusion Detection and Prevention Systems: Guide to IDPS

Intrusion Detection and Prevention Systems (IDPS) operate by monitoring network traffic, analyzing it and providing remediation tactics when malicious behavior is detected. They look for matching behavior or characteristics that would indicate malicious traffic, send out alerts and block attacks.

Having both the capabilities of detection and prevention are vital to effective security infrastructure. Detection only identifies malicious behavior but won’t take action to block or prevent attacks when one is detected. It will solely log these alerts. Prevention systems can adjust firewall rules on the fly to block or drop malicious traffic when it is detected but they do not have the robust identification capabilities of detection systems.

IDPS tools can detect malware, socially engineered attacks and other web-based threats, including DDoS attacks. They can also provide preemptive intrusion prevention capabilities for internal threats and potentially compromised systems.

Keep in mind while reviewing our list of top IDPS software tools that you may not need to purchase them as standalone products. They may also be included with other security tools, such as next-generation firewalls (NGFW), and can go by other names, such as threat prevention.

Top Intrusion Detection and Prevention Systems

  • McAfee NSP
  • Trend Micro TippingPoint
  • Darktrace Enterprise Immune System
  • Cisco Firepower NGIPS
  • AT&T Cybersecurity USM
  • Palo Alto Networks Threat Prevention
  • Blumira Automated Detection & Response
  • NSFocus NGIPS

 

Features McAfee NSP Trend Micro TippingPoint Darktrace Enterprise Immune System Cisco Firepower NGIPS AT&T USM  Palo Alto Networks Threat Prevention Blumira Automated Detection & Response NSFocus NGIPS
Signature based Yes No No (Pattern of Life) Yes Yes Yes No Yes
Anomaly based Yes Yes No (Pattern of Life) Yes Yes No Yes Yes
Cloud compatible Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Price Starts from $10,995 Starts at $6,000 Darktrace offers a 30-day trial that is valued at between $10,000 and $20,000. Contact the vendor directly for a quote. Firepower 4120 tested by NSS Labs sells for around $100,000 Starts at $5,595 Contact vendor for quote Starts $1,200/mo Contact vendor for quote

 

McAfee NSP

The McAfee Network Security Platform (NSP) is a next-generation intrusion detection and prevention solution that protects systems and data wherever they reside, across data centers, the cloud and hybrid enterprise environments. McAfee has long been one of the largest names in cybersecurity and has proven why with this comprehensive IDPS product.

It can support up to 32 million connections on a single appliance and uses intelligence to find and block sophisticated malware threats and advanced targeted attacks across a network. It offers intelligent bot analytics, improved endpoint application monitoring, flow data analysis, self-learning DoS profiles and an analytics function for identifying potentially malicious hosts.

Users praise McAfee NSP for its flexibility, comprehensive architecture and simple operability. When it comes to hardware, NSP can meet the full range of customer needs with its four sensor models.

Trend Micro TippingPoint

Trend Micro TippingPoint identifies and blocks malicious traffic, prevents lateral movement of malware, ensures network availability and resiliency and enhances network performance. It can be deployed into the network with no IP or MAC address to immediately filter out malicious and unwanted traffic. Digital Vaccine threat intelligence security filters cover the entire vulnerability footprint, not just specific exploits. The solution offers network traffic inspection throughput up to 120 Gbps.

TippingPoint uses a combination of technologies, such as deep packet inspection and threat reputation, to take a proactive approach to network security. Its in-depth analysis of traffic ensures high accuracy of threat detection and provides contextual awareness to give security teams a better understanding of how to remediate a threat. TippingPoint solutions are provided as hardware or virtual platforms and provide real-time, vulnerability protection through Automated Vaccine Threat Intelligence.

Darktrace Enterprise Immune System

The Darktrace Enterprise Immune System is machine learning and artificial intelligence (AI) technology for cyber defense. It lives up to its name by modeling its functionality after the human immune system. It iteratively learns a unique “pattern of life” for every device and user on a network, and correlates these insights to spot emerging threats that would otherwise go unnoticed.

Darktrace Enterprise Immune System can also implement automatic prevention efforts to give security teams precious time to fight back. This system can detect threats in cloud environments, corporate networks and industrial control systems. Darktrace’s award-winning threat visualizer provides holistic visibility into the network security infrastructure and complete oversight of the AI’s alerts and actions.

Darktrace does not consider itself an IPS or IDPS solution, and Gartner agrees that the company does not fit that category. However, the analyst firm named it a vendor to watch in this area of the market. This IDPS product is available as a software and hardware appliance.

Cisco Firepower NGIPS

Cisco’s Next-Generation Intrusion Prevention System comes in software and physical and virtual appliances for small branch offices up to large enterprises, offering throughput of 50 Mbps up to 60 Mbps. NGIPS offers URL-based security intelligence, AMP Threat Grid integration, and is backed by the company’s Talos security research team.

The Firepower Management Center provides contextual data on threats to help teams identify what kind of threat they are facing and helps find the root cause of the issue. Cisco updates Firepower with new signatures every two hours, ensuring the system is able to detect the newest, most advanced threats.

Gartner has ranked Cisco Firepower NGIPS as a Magic Quadrant Leader for seven years running, and the independent NSS Labs testing organization has deemed it a “Recommended” IPS solution for the last eight years.

AT&T Cybersecurity USM

AT&T Cybersecurity Unified Security Management (USM) – formerly AlienVault – delivers threat detection, incident response, and compliance management in one unified platform. It integrates five essential components of a comprehensive security solution: Asset discovery, vulnerability assessment, intrusion detection, behavioral monitoring and SIEM log management.

Continually updated threat intelligence from both AlienVault Labs and the AlienVault Open Threat Exchange keeps the system up-to-date on malicious actors, threats, tools and methods. It also delivers context on the latest alarms and vulnerabilities to save teams the time of doing the research themselves. Its alarm system categorizes threats based on the level of risk to help security teams prioritize responses.

Its robust search and filtering capabilities allow teams to isolate alarms or events of interest so they can dig into details of information on threats, related events, as well as recommendations for incident responses. There is also a long list of incident response options that can be launched directly from the console.

AlienVault USM can be deployed across on-premises and cloud environments.

Palo Alto Networks

Palo Alto Networks is likely most famous for its powerful next-generation firewalls. The Palo Alto Networks Threat Prevention product was developed to accelerate the capabilities of their NGFW through intelligent scanning and prevention. It aims to prevent successful cyberattacks through automation.

Threat Prevention can inspect all traffic with full user context, automatically preventing known threats, regardless of port, protocol or SSL encryption. Its threat intelligence is automatically updated every day, delivered to the NGFW and implemented by Threat Prevention to stop all threats.

Palo Alto Networks also made an effort to ensure consistent impressive performance. Its single-pass architecture and policy management provide full threat detection and prevention without sacrificing performance.

NSFocus NGIPS

The NSFocus Next-Generation Intrusion Prevention System (NGIPS) provides threat protection that blocks intrusions, prevents breaches and safeguards assets. It uses a multi-layer approach to identify and address known, zero-day and advanced persistent threats to protect from malware, worms, spyware, backdoor trojans, data leakage, brute force cracking, protocol attacks, scanning/probing and web threats.

It supports the processing capacity of up to 20 Gbps of application-layer data. The NSFocus Virtual sandboxing tool can identify, evaluate and mitigate known and advanced persistent threats.

NSFocus NGIPS is available as both physical and virtual machines.

Blumira Automated Detection & Response

Blumira Automated Detection & Response platform enables organizations to more efficiently defend against cybersecurity threats in near real-time. It is designed to cut through the noise of false positive alerts and only focus attention on true malicious behavior to ease the burden of alert fatigue.

Beyond identifying threats, Blumira’s automated threat response works in near-real-time to stop insider and external threats. The system also includes step-by-step playbooks to guide remediation efforts. The management dashboard provides further insights into threats over time, open analysis and suspected threats.

Blumira is a completely cloud-delivered platform so it can easily and quickly be deployed. And with robust security orchestration and automation built into this IDPS, it can be managed by teams of virtually any size.

Primary Intrusion Detection and Prevention System Functions

The primary functions of IDPS solutions can be broken down into four main categories:

  • Monitoring: IDPS monitors IT systems using either signature-based or anomaly-based intrusion detection to identify abnormal behavior and signature malicious activity.
  • Alerts: After identifying potential threats, IDPS software will log and send out alert notifications to Inform administrators of abnormal activity.
  • Remediation: IDPS tools provide blocking mechanisms for malicious threats, giving administrators time to take action. In some cases, IT teams may not be required to take action at all after an attack is blocked.
  • Maintenance: Besides monitoring for abnormal behavior, IDPS tools can also monitor the performance of IT hardware and security components with health checks. This ensures a security infrastructure is operating properly at all times.

Intrusion detection systems (IDS) vs. Intrusion prevention systems (IPS)

As previously mentioned, a truly holistic IDPS tool requires both detection and prevention capabilities. When browsing for solutions, you will likely come across both intrusion detection systems (IDS) and intrusion prevention systems (IPS). These are standalone products and should not be confused with IDPS, which will help you avoid large holes in your security infrastructure.

IDS tools are only designed to detect malicious activity and log and send out alerts. They are not capable of preventing an attack. The alerts they raise always require human intervention.

IPS, on the other hand, responds based on predetermined criteria of types of attacks by blocking traffic and dropping malicious processes. Unfortunately, IPS tools lead to more false positives as they have inferior detection capabilities compared to IDS.

IDPS solutions incorporate the strengths of both systems into one product or suite of products.

Types of IDPS

The types of IDPS can be classified according to what they are designed to protect. They generally fall under two types: host-based and network-based.

Host-Based IDPS

Host-based IDPS is software deployed on the host that solely monitors traffic to connect to and from that host. It typically only protects a single, specific endpoint. In some cases, it may also monitor system files stored on the host for unauthorized changes and processes running on the system.

Network-Based IDPS

Network-based IDPS, also sometimes called network intrusion detection systems (NIDS), are deployed in a place where it can monitor traffic for an entire network segment or subnet. Their functionality somewhat resembles firewalls, which are only able to prevent intrusions coming from outside the network and enforce access control lists (ACLs) between networks.

NIDS are designed to detect and alert on potential malicious internal traffic moving laterally throughout a network; this makes it a great tool for a zero trust security framework. The traffic is analyzed for signs of malicious behavior based on the profiles of common types of attacks.

Intrusion detection methodologies

These systems identify potential threats based on built-in rules and profiles. The most common are signature-based and anomaly-based detection methodologies.

Signature-based intrusion detection

Signature-based intrusion detection looks for instances of known attacks. When malicious content is identified, it is analyzed for unique features to create a fingerprint, or signature, for that specific attack. This signature could be in the form of a known identity or pattern of behavior. Signature-based systems then compare this fingerprint to a database of pre-existing signatures to identify the specific type of attack. The downside to these systems is that they must be updated regularly to be able to recognize new and evolving types of attacks.

Anomaly-based intrusion detection

Anomaly-based intrusion detection builds an initial model of “normal” behavior for a specific system rather than creating fingerprints. The system will then compare all real-time behavior against the previously created normal model to identify behavioral anomalies. These instances of abnormal behavior are used to identify potential attacks and trigger alerts.

Contrasting signature-based vs. anomaly-based IDPS

There are issues with both of these systems individually. Signature-based detection has low false positives but can only detect known attacks. This makes them vulnerable to new, evolving attack methods.

Anomaly-based detection can lead to high false positives as it alerts on all anomalous behavior. But it has the potential to catch zero-day threats. Fortunately, many IDPS products combine both methodologies to complement their strengths and weaknesses.

Challenges when managing IDPS

You may experience some challenges when it comes to IDPS software tools. Here are a few to keep top-of-mind:

  • False positives: You will almost surely run into the problem of false-positive alerts, which can waste time and resources. Be vigilant when you’re notified of potentially malicious behavior, but also be aware that it’s not a guarantee of an attack.
  • Staffing: Cybersecurity is so essential to modern organizations that there is currently a shortage of available security professionals. Before implementing an IDPS system, ensure you’ve put together a team that has the capabilities to effectively manage it.
  • Genuine risks: Beyond just managing an IDPS, there will be cases where administrator intervention is required. An IDPS can block many attacks but not all. Make sure teams keep their knowledge-up-to-date on new types of attacks so they’re not blindsided when one is identified.
Avatar
Kyle Guercio
Kyle Guercio has worked in content creation for six years contributing blog posts, featured news articles, press releases, white papers, and more for a wide variety of subjects in the technology space. He covers topics relating to servers and cybersecurity and has contributed to ServerWatch and Webopedia.com.

Top Products

Top Cybersecurity Companies

Cybersecurity is the hottest area of IT spending. That's why so many vendors have entered this lucrative $100 billion+ market. But who are the...

Top Endpoint Detection and Response (EDR) Solutions

Endpoint security is a cornerstone of IT security, so our team put considerable research and analysis into this list of top endpoint detection and...

Top CASB Security Vendors for 2021

Any cloud-based infrastructure needs a robust cloud access security broker (CASB) solution to ensure data and application...

Best SIEM Tools & Software for 2021

Security Information and Event Management (SIEM, pronounced "sim") is a key enterprise security technology, with the ability...

Related articles