Coalition Warns AI Cyberattacks Could Increase Insurance Losses

Coalition warns AI cyberattacks could increase insurance claims and premiums as BEC and financial fraud become more frequent.

Written By
Ken Underhill
Ken Underhill
Nov 16, 2026
3 minute read
eSecurity Planet content and product recommendations are editorially independent. We may make money when you click on links to our partners. Learn More

Artificial intelligence (AI) is changing the economics of cybercrime, increasing the frequency of familiar attacks without necessarily creating widespread catastrophic losses.

I spoke with Daniel Woods, head of emerging risks at Coalition, via email about how AI-enabled threats are influencing cyber insurance claims.

We also discussed why widespread vulnerability exposure does not always result in significant financial losses and what organizations can do to strengthen their defenses.

Why AI-driven cyber catastrophes remain unlikely

According to Woods, catastrophic cyber losses could result from a major outage affecting a widely used service or malware that spreads across numerous organizations.

Advertisement

AI service outages are a particular concern because businesses rely on these platforms for automated workflows. A widespread disruption could interrupt operations and cause financial losses for multiple customers.

However, Woods considers self-replicating AI malware less realistic. Traditional malware can already spread autonomously. The computational requirements of large language models (LLMs) offer limited advantages, especially against resource-constrained devices.

Instead, he expects AI to increase attritional risk, which refers to the financial impact of frequent individual claims. A substantial increase in these claims could ultimately produce losses comparable to a single catastrophic event.

Why widespread vulnerabilities do not guarantee major losses

Recent vulnerabilities illustrate the difference between potential exposure and actual financial losses.

Woods pointed to the Black October PHP vulnerabilities, which potentially exposed thousands of organizations running different versions of the software.

Despite their broad reach, successful exploitation remains technically challenging. Attackers must overcome memory protections and develop exploits tailored to specific software environments.

Advertisement

Coalition estimated approximately $46.8 billion in potential exposure across more than 32,000 policyholders notified about PHP vulnerabilities. However, Woods emphasized that this figure represents a theoretical maximum if every affected policyholder experienced a full-limit loss simultaneously.

For comparison, Coalition's 2026 Cyber Claims Report reported average ransomware claim severity of $121,195 in 2025.

Woods expects an increase in claims associated with these vulnerabilities, but not losses reaching catastrophic levels across the industry.

AI is accelerating business email compromise and financial fraud

Coalition's claims data suggests AI is already influencing the frequency of common cyberattacks.

According to Woods, business email compromise (BEC) claim frequency increased approximately 30% between the second half of 2024 and the second half of 2025, with continued growth into 2026.

He linked this increase to subscription-based phishing kits that automate attacks and can bypass multifactor authentication (MFA). Some cost approximately $500 monthly, making smaller organizations more attractive targets.

AI also contributes to funds transfer fraud through convincing impersonation attempts. Attackers can use deepfake videos to deliver fraudulent instructions or automate email-based fraud campaigns.

Advertisement

Woods referenced a Microsoft investigation involving approximately one million fraudulent emails distributed during a September campaign.

Social engineering remains a significant factor in these incidents. Coalition reported that BEC and funds transfer fraud accounted for 58% of its 2025 claims. Social engineering was involved in 71% of funds transfer fraud claims.

These findings suggest AI is making established attack methods more accessible and scalable. They also highlight the importance of strengthening employee awareness and financial verification controls.

Human expertise still limits autonomous cyberattacks

Despite advances in AI capabilities, Woods identified several challenges that continue to limit fully autonomous ransomware operations.

Attackers still need to navigate complex networks and identify valuable assets. Turning unauthorized access into financial gain also requires expertise, particularly when targeting organizations with mature security defenses.

Woods said his assessment would change if AI could reliably exploit vulnerabilities across different platforms or enable attackers to move from initial access to widespread ransomware deployment without skilled human operators.

Advertisement

For now, he expects AI to accelerate existing cybercrime rather than fundamentally change how catastrophic cyberattacks occur.

What rising cyber risks mean for insurance premiums

Woods expects cyber insurance premiums to increase as vulnerabilities become more prevalent and claims continue to rise.

He noted that ransomware remains a significant driver of financial losses, accounting for approximately 55% of incurred losses.

For security teams, I believe the most important takeaway from our discussion is the need to strengthen financial fraud prevention alongside technical security defenses.

Woods recommends requiring finance teams to verify changes to payment instructions through callbacks to trusted, pre-existing telephone numbers. High-risk transfers should also require dual approval.

These measures can help organizations reduce financial exposure as AI makes impersonation attempts more convincing.

For additional guidance, see how stronger identity verification can help prevent deepfake-enabled fraud.

Ken Underhill

Ken Underhill is an award-winning cybersecurity professional, bestselling author, and seasoned IT professional. He holds a graduate degree in cybersecurity and information assurance from Western Governors University and brings years of hands-on experience to the field.

eSecurity Planet Logo

eSecurity Planet is a leading resource for IT professionals at large enterprises who are actively researching cybersecurity vendors and latest trends. eSecurity Planet focuses on providing instruction for how to approach common security challenges, as well as informational deep-dives about advanced cybersecurity topics.

Property of TechnologyAdvice. © 2026 TechnologyAdvice. All Rights Reserved

Advertiser Disclosure: Some of the products that appear on this site are from companies from which TechnologyAdvice receives compensation. This compensation may impact how and where products appear on this site including, for example, the order in which they appear. TechnologyAdvice does not include all companies or all types of products available in the marketplace.