The AI Shortcut Cybersecurity Leaders Should Avoid

AI in cybersecurity can improve efficiency, but security leaders must balance automation with hands-on training to develop analyst skills and sound judgment.

Written By
Arve Kjoelen
Arve Kjoelen
Nov 16, 2026
4 minute read
closeup photo of turned-on blue and white laptop computer

AI can speed up cybersecurity investigations, but junior analysts still need hands-on experience to build sound judgment. Image: Philipp Katzenberger/Unsplash.

eSecurity Planet content and product recommendations are editorially independent. We may make money when you click on links to our partners. Learn More

AI is helping cybersecurity teams move faster, but it’s also changing how future defenders learn.

Letting AI supply answers before analysts develop their own judgment is the shortcut security leaders need to avoid. Cybersecurity teams don’t learn to separate real threats from noise by reading the answer. They learn through hands-on work: working through messy evidence, making a call, and finding out whether that call was right.

This matters because cybersecurity is adversarial work. Early-career professionals have to understand how attackers think, how to interpret small anomalies and how to recognize when something routine may be dangerous. 

This kind of adversarial judgment takes practice. If AI gives them the answer too early, they may start to review conclusions before they know how to form their own.

AI can absolutely help cybersecurity teams. It can analyze signals, summarize incidents, and remove repetitive tasks from teams under constant pressure. Without a workforce strategy, though, AI becomes another way to ask more from people who are already stretched thin.

AI is already changing the cybersecurity workforce

Advertisement

Recent SANS workforce research found that 74% of cybersecurity teams are changing their structures and role assignments because of AI, with entry-level SOC and security analyst roles among the most affected. 

ISSA research found that 68% of cybersecurity professionals believe their jobs have become harder over the past two years, and nearly half have considered leaving their current role.

During a recent incident, one of our most experienced analysts used AI automation to quickly investigate a large amount of logs. But at the end, the analyst had a feeling something was still amiss. 

It turned out the automation didn’t have access to a whole class of logs that still needed to be investigated. Without that intuition and understanding of our environment, a less experienced analyst might have concluded the investigation too soon with a less reliable conclusion, and no one would have been the wiser.

The same road map that looks efficient in a security operations review can quietly erase critical points in the development path for the people who are supposed to become tomorrow’s senior analysts, architects and security leaders.

Advertisement

Protect the work that builds judgment

Many security careers are built through hands-on repetition. Junior analysts investigate phishing emails, triage alerts, review suspicious activity and practice assessing the seriousness of each case. 

The work isn’t always exciting, but it builds the pattern recognition and judgment analysts need as they take on more complex decisions.

It also teaches people how to communicate. A junior analyst builds that skill by documenting what happened, explaining its importance and presenting a recommendation to someone outside security. Those moments are where technical knowledge starts to become business judgment.

AI can now assist with much of that work, reshaping entry-level cybersecurity roles. The problem comes when organizations remove too much of the learning layer without replacing it with mentorship, training, and real ownership.

In a phishing investigation, AI shouldn’t always give the junior analyst the answer first. A better model is to have the analyst:

  • Review the message.
  • Write the first recommendation.
  • Explain why the alert matters.
  • Compare their reasoning with the AI output.
Advertisement

AI works best as a coach when it checks the analyst’s reasoning after the analyst has formed an initial view.

Treat AI as a workforce design issue

Each AI workflow alters what people practice, what they skip and how they build confidence in their decisions. 

While AI may handle the first draft, the first triage, or the first recommendation, leaders need to be clear about where human review still matters and how junior employees will keep developing sound judgment.

Cybersecurity already faces a skills challenge. Many organizations receive plenty of applications and still struggle to find candidates with the right experience for emerging roles, particularly in AI security and governance. 

Leaders can’t hire their way out of that problem and need to build talent inside their organizations.

AI should become part of that development model. It can help junior employees improve faster by explaining incidents, surfacing context and showing how experienced analysts think through problems. That outcome won’t happen automatically because a company bought another AI-enabled tool.

Advertisement

Burnout makes the talent challenge harder. Senior security professionals who are already overloaded have less time to coach junior employees, review their work and explain how they reached a decision. 

Security professionals don’t burn out because they lack commitment. They burn out when demands keep expanding, priorities remain unclear, tools stay fragmented and the organization expects heroics as a normal way of operating. AI won’t fix that environment.

Use AI to build capability, not just efficiency

The companies that succeed with AI will use it to eliminate low-value work while protecting the experiences that build future talent. 

That starts with identifying:

  • What people still need to learn.
  • Where human judgment matters most.
  • How junior employees become capable decision-makers.

Cybersecurity still depends on people who can bring context, take responsibility and make judgment calls when the answer isn’t obvious. Leaders need to make sure AI strengthens those abilities rather than quietly stripping away the experiences that help people develop them.

Security leaders need to ask what AI can take off the team’s plate and what their newest analysts still need to experience. Those analysts still need to make the call, test their reasoning and learn from the result. 

Advertisement

AI should sharpen that instinct, not short-circuit it.

Read more: How lean SOC teams can scale expertise and strengthen security operations.

Arve Kjoelen

Arve Kjoelen is the CISO at Barracuda. A cybersecurity leader with more than 25 years of experience, he has led global security programs across technology and financial services organizations, including serving as Global CISO at McAfee. He previously held leadership roles at CyberGRX, EY, Wells Fargo, and Bridgewater, and most recently served as Chief Solutions Officer at Cybriq Solutions. Arve specializes in cyber resilience, risk management, security operations, and the impact of AI on cybersecurity.

eSecurity Planet Logo

eSecurity Planet is a leading resource for IT professionals at large enterprises who are actively researching cybersecurity vendors and latest trends. eSecurity Planet focuses on providing instruction for how to approach common security challenges, as well as informational deep-dives about advanced cybersecurity topics.

Property of TechnologyAdvice. © 2026 TechnologyAdvice. All Rights Reserved

Advertiser Disclosure: Some of the products that appear on this site are from companies from which TechnologyAdvice receives compensation. This compensation may impact how and where products appear on this site including, for example, the order in which they appear. TechnologyAdvice does not include all companies or all types of products available in the marketplace.